By Victoria Bechtold, PhD Student Sociology Department, Virginia Tech
Mayapple (Podophyllum peltatum)
Chemical Components
Podophyllotoxin was initially described in 1753, and later isolated as a solitary compound in 1880.1 This compound, and mayapple plants more broadly, were historically applied for a wide range of conditions or ailments. Shah et al., in a 2021 publication, list a number of these conditions, including:
- constipation
- tuberculosis
- menstrual disorders
- psoriasis (a chronic condition characterized by dry or scaly skin)
- dropsy (another term for edema, or swelling and excessive fluid accumulation under the skin)
- gout (an arthritic condition)
- tumors
- coughs
- gonorrhea
- syphilis
- venereal warts
Modern medical research, as summarised by Drs. Yu, Che, and Xu in a 2017 publication, suggests that podophyllotoxin is effective in a lab setting as a:
- cytotoxic agent (it effectively kills cells; more research is investigating its efficacy against tumors and other cancerous cells)
- insecticide
- antifungal
- antiviral
- anti-inflammatory
- neurotoxin
- immunosuppressant antirheumatic (combatting symptoms and effects of arthritis)
- antioxidant
- antispasmodic (reducing the prevalence or severity of seizures)
- hypolipidemic activities (reducing the prevalence of lipids in the body; lowers cholesterol)
However, medical literature suggests that podophyllotoxin has a number of undesirable side effects when used, significantly limiting its clinical applications 2 (Yu, Che, and Xu 2017). Some of these side effects include:
- gastrointestinal toxicity (e.g., constipation, diarrhea, etc.)
- neurotoxicity
- hair-loss
- bone marrow suppression (compromising the ability of the bone marrow to generate white blood cells and red blood cells)
Nevertheless, researchers continue to study podophyllotoxin for its capacity to be chemically modified. By chemically modifying the structure of this molecule in a process referred to as “structure optimization”, scientists are synthesizing derivative molecules with different uses and potentially fewer side effects.3 Three such derivatives include etoposide, teniposide, and etopophos.
Etoposide is a derivative of podophyllotoxin that is currently being investigated for potential use as an anti-cancer agent and as a potential intervention against cytokine storm syndrome.
Research on etoposide in cancer treatment
Cancer is the unregulated division of mutated cells in the body, ultimately compromising the body’s ability to function. In malignant cancers, this occurs as groups of cancer cells, called tumors, grow and eventually destroy the necessary cells in the body. Groups of cells make up tissues, and groups of tissues comprise organs; once tumors destroy enough healthy tissue, affected organs shut down.
There are many reasons why an individual may develop cancer. Similarly, there are a multitude of types of cancer, and there is currently no standard treatment capable of curing all types of cancer. Some treatments currently in use include surgery (which involves removing the cancerous tissues from the body), chemotherapy (which involves the use of drugs to prevent cancer cells from replicating), and radiation therapy (which uses charged particles like protons and electrons to destroy DNA in cancer cells, preventing cell replication, and leading to tumor shrinkage).4 Other treatments or therapies for combatting cancer are still under development.
The issue with many of these extant cancer treatments is that they affect functional and necessary body cells as well as cancerous cells. This means that there is considerable harm done to healthy tissues when undergoing cancer treatment, (which is why cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy or radiation therapy tend to exhibit symptoms of illness), but these healthy cells tend to have more of a capacity to recover from the damages caused by treatment than the cancer cells do.
As stated above, modern cancer treatments often target the cell replication process in an effort to stop cancer cells from replicating, arresting the growth of the tumor. Human cells (other than sperm and egg cells) replicate through a process called mitosis. During mitosis, the cell generates a copy of its DNA, condenses that DNA into a structure called a chromosome, then splits those chromosomes in half, and pulls the identical halves to either end of the cell. At that point, the cell splits into two, with each new daughter cell containing the same genetic information as the original parent cell. Within this process, the point at which the half-chromosomes, or chromatids, are pulled to separate ends of the cell requires a structure called a mitotic spindle which serves as the rope that both anchors the chromatids to each end of the cell, and which pulls them to that end.
Etoposide is being investigated as a chemotherapeutic agent that works by inhibiting the ability of cells to create tubulin, the protein that makes up the metaphorical fibers of the metaphorical rope of those mitotic spindles.5 Without these proteins, the mitotic spindles cannot form, and without the mitotic spindles, the cell cannot replicate. This leads to the arrest of tumor growth.
Use of etoposide as a chemotherapeutic is currently limited for three primary reasons. First, it is myelosuppressive.6 This means that it attacks bone marrow, which limits the body’s ability to produce red blood cells (necessary for the circulation of oxygen) and white blood cells (necessary for the maintenance and function of the immune system). Similar to other chemotherapeutic drugs, there have been clinical cases where tumors have developed drug-resistance to etoposide, limiting its long-term efficacy.7 Lastly, etoposide, like other chemotherapeutics, does not only damage cancer cells, but damages and kills healthy body cells as well. Nevertheless, researchers are continuing to investigate etoposide as a means of using chemotherapy against tumors that have grown resistant to the more commonly applied chemotherapeutic treatments.8
Research on etoposide in managing cytokine storm syndrome
Further research is exploring the potential application of etoposide as an intervention to mitigate the effects of cytokine storm syndrome. Cytokine storm syndrome is a process by which a person’s immune system recognizes a threat (e.g., a virus, like COVID-19, or an accumulation of dead or infected cells, resulting in sepsis), and launches an immune response.9 This immune response particularly releases cytotoxic t-cells, which are a type of white blood cell that will destroy damaged or infected cells within the body as a method of preventing the further spread of the inciting threat. However, in some cases (particularly in cases like COVID-19), this means that this immune response ends up destroying more cells than the body can afford to lose, potentially resulting in organ failure, and sometimes, death.10
Etoposide, when administered in clinical settings, has demonstrated a capacity to kill some of the cytotoxic t-cells during a cytokine storm, slowing down organ deterioration and giving clinicians time to administer alternative drugs and treatments to address the primary cause of the cytokine storm.11
Based on this preliminary evidence and the lack of information available about COVID-19 and potential available treatments at the time, a team of clinicians documented their use of etoposide for a patient experiencing multiple complications due to COVID-19, including cytokine storm syndrome, in 2020.12 There were a number of interventions with more supporting evidence that these care providers attempted to administer over the course of the patient’s first 20 days in the hospital, but as the patient’s condition continued to deteriorate, they turned to etoposide. They administered two doses of etoposide, one week apart, and after another five days, the patient improved enough to be transferred out of the ICU. Later they were able to adequately breathe on their own, so they were removed from the ventilator, underwent physical therapy, and were later released from the hospital.13
This is a single case study, meaning no broad conclusions about the use of etoposide in the management of COVID-19 and cytokine storm syndrome should be drawn at this juncture. Nevertheless, future research will likely continue to explore the use of etoposide in the management of these conditions and reach a more definitive conclusion.
Cautions:
All parts of the Mayapple plant are poisonous except for the fully ripe fruit.14 The roots, leaves, stems, seeds, and underripe fruit is toxic to humans, cattle, and swine, and could lead to severe bowel discomfort and vomiting.15 Exercise extreme caution when harvesting mayapple fruit to eat, and consult multiple sources to identify the plant and to verify the ripeness of the fruit.
- Shah, Zinnia, Umar Farooq Gohar, Iffat Jamshed, Aamir Mushtaq, Hamid Mukhtar, Muhammad Zia-UI-Haq, Sebastian Ionut Toma, Rosana Manea, Marius Moga, and Bianca Popovici. 2021. “Podophyllotoxin: History, Recent Advances and Future Prospects.” Biomolecules 11(4):603. doi: 10.3390/biom11040603.Back to top.
- Yu, Xiang, Zhiping Che, and Hui Xu. 2017. “Recent Advances in the Chemistry and Biology of Podophyllotoxins.” Chemistry – A European Journal 23(19):4467–4526. doi: 10.1002/chem.201602472.Back to top.
- Shah, Zinnia, Umar Farooq Gohar, Iffat Jamshed, Aamir Mushtaq, Hamid Mukhtar, Muhammad Zia-UI-Haq, Sebastian Ionut Toma, Rosana Manea, Marius Moga, and Bianca Popovici. 2021. “Podophyllotoxin: History, Recent Advances and Future Prospects.” Biomolecules 11(4):603. doi: 10.3390/biom11040603.Back to top.
- Qazi, Asma Saleem. 2023. “Introduction and Overview of Cancer Therapeutics.” Pp. 1–13 in Therapeutic Approaches in Cancer Treatment, edited by A. S. Qazi and K. Tariq. Cham: Springer International Publishing.Back to top.
- Shah, Zinnia, Umar Farooq Gohar, Iffat Jamshed, Aamir Mushtaq, Hamid Mukhtar, Muhammad Zia-UI-Haq, Sebastian Ionut Toma, Rosana Manea, Marius Moga, and Bianca Popovici. 2021. “Podophyllotoxin: History, Recent Advances and Future Prospects.” Biomolecules 11(4):603. doi: 10.3390/biom11040603.Back to top.
- Shah, Zinnia, Umar Farooq Gohar, Iffat Jamshed, Aamir Mushtaq, Hamid Mukhtar, Muhammad Zia-UI-Haq, Sebastian Ionut Toma, Rosana Manea, Marius Moga, and Bianca Popovici. 2021. “Podophyllotoxin: History, Recent Advances and Future Prospects.” Biomolecules 11(4):603. doi: 10.3390/biom11040603.Back to top.
- Shah, Zinnia, Umar Farooq Gohar, Iffat Jamshed, Aamir Mushtaq, Hamid Mukhtar, Muhammad Zia-UI-Haq, Sebastian Ionut Toma, Rosana Manea, Marius Moga, and Bianca Popovici. 2021. “Podophyllotoxin: History, Recent Advances and Future Prospects.” Biomolecules 11(4):603. doi: 10.3390/biom11040603.Back to top.
- Ardalani, Hamidreza, Amir Avan, and Majid Ghayour-Mobarhan. 2017. “Podophyllotoxin: A Novel Potential Natural Anticancer Agent.” Avicenna Journal of Phytomedicine 7(4):285–94.Back to top.
- Jarczak, Dominik, and Axel Nierhaus. 2022. “Cytokine Storm—Definition, Causes, and Implications.” International Journal of Molecular Sciences 23(19):11740. doi: 10.3390/ijms231911740.Back to top.
- Jarczak, Dominik, and Axel Nierhaus. 2022. “Cytokine Storm—Definition, Causes, and Implications.” International Journal of Molecular Sciences 23(19):11740. doi: 10.3390/ijms231911740.Back to top.
- Fajgenbaum, David C., and Carl H. June. 2020. “Cytokine Storm.” The New England Journal of Medicine 383(23):2255–73. doi: 10.1056/NEJMra2026131.Back to top.
- Patel, Maulin, Eduardo Dominguez, Daniel Sacher, Parag Desai, Ashwin Chandar, Michael Bromberg, Roberto Caricchio, and Gerard J. Criner. 2021. “Etoposide as Salvage Therapy for Cytokine Storm Due to Coronavirus Disease 2019.” Chest 159(1):e7–11. doi: 10.1016/j.chest.2020.09.077.Back to top.
- Patel, Maulin, Eduardo Dominguez, Daniel Sacher, Parag Desai, Ashwin Chandar, Michael Bromberg, Roberto Caricchio, and Gerard J. Criner. 2021. “Etoposide as Salvage Therapy for Cytokine Storm Due to Coronavirus Disease 2019.” Chest 159(1):e7–11. doi: 10.1016/j.chest.2020.09.077.Back to top.
- Schmitt, Paul S. n.d. “Mayapple.” Cornell Botanic Gardens. Retrieved December 12, 2024 (https://cornellbotanicgardens.org/plant/mayapple/).Back to top.
- Nice, Glenn. 2021. “It’s May, So Its Mayapple Season.” Purdue University - College of Agriculture. Retrieved December 12, 2024 (https://ag.purdue.edu/department/btny/ppdl/potw-dept-folder/2021/mayapple.html).Back to top.
