By Makenna K. Clark, PhD Student Sociology Department, Virginia Tech
How to Inherit 600 Acres and Heal: An Oral History Project
One Appalachian’s Experience of Land Inheritance, Regional Identity, Ecological Restoration and Climate Resilience
What feels really good is that if you give a plant or a project the right conditions to grow, it will grow.
erin is a white Appalachian “femme-ish” person in her 40s, born and raised in Blacksburg, VA. She spent her childhood roaming the rolling hills and valleys of her family’s 600-acre farm that her grandfather bought in the 1970s. Land which she has since inherited. During our ninety-minute interview, erin openly shared about her life, discussing themes related to Appalachian identity, land inheritance, climate change and resilience, land stewardship, and the contours of living in a region and town that has “grown and lost so much.”
I interviewed erin on an abnormally warm Fall Day in 2024. After driving down a long, dirt driveway towards the rolling mountain ahead, I pulled off to the left and was greeted by erin’s dog, Sally. Sally and I walked up to erin’s front door, and I was warmly welcomed into a small, lofted log cabin. Cascading plants, animal bones, dried herbs, artwork, and books decorated the walls of erin’s home. Once settled in one another’s company, I began our interview by prompting erin to “Tell me about the land we are on.” Her description was slow, rich with historical insight, and unapologetically textured. It reflected the kind of intimacy only a forty-year-long relationship could.
erin described the land as a third parent, one that provided safe childcare and nurtured her blossoming imagination. While erin’s mom worked inside their home cooking dinner or grading papers, she played in the woods or by the creek with her friends and brother, imagining a time long before her that unfolded on the very ground she stood. erin’s mother would ring a heavy cast iron triangle when it was time to come in, and she would do it all over again the next day.
Throughout our ninety-minute interview, erin answered my questions thoughtfully and tenderly—evidence that she spends much of her private time contemplating her relationships with place, purpose, and identity. Ways of belonging and Appalachian culture were woven into erin’s childhood formally in school and informally through play and family norms. erin recalled school projects designed to educate and cultivate children’s Appalachian cultural identity. At home, Sunday drives with her dad to Floyd and Craig counties in Southwestern Virginia were regular. As she processed dried elecampane seated crisscross applesauce on the couch, she explained her father’s intentions:
He really wanted to impart on my brother and I how special it was that these folks were real living, old-timer Appalachian folks…there was some class difference between my family and some of these folks who we went to go visit… they were more- my mom was a professor. We had grown up with more land privilege and class privilege than some.I think some of what my dad was trying to instill was his pride in these folks, his kind of respect for these folks who were from a similar but more kind of salt of the earthy background. But I do remember him talking about Appalachia. Being proud. Instilling that we come from a cool and special place, “you kids don't know how good you got it that we live around here,” kind of thing.
I didn't know how good I had it until we moved away, and then I was really homesick.
erin doesn’t remember her mom discussing Appalachia as an explicit concept in her childhood, though family meals with her maternal grandparents would feature recurring stories about their depression-era roots, with their rural beginnings highlighting real contrast with the wealth they achieved. Her family does have deep roots with many generations on both sides connecting her to the region. Her mom went on to study and teach Appalachian Studies primarily through a literature lens and other academic cultural studies lenses. erin’s relationship with place and belonging guided her involvement in grassroots organizing efforts related to resource extraction and environmental justice, and she suspects her work doing anti-strip-mining organizing, “which at the time was very Appalachian cultural flavored,” had an impact on her mom’s pursuit of Appalachian Studies:
We would have old-time String Band fundraisers with a square dance. We organized an annual pie auction with a live auctioneer to support organizing efforts in the coal fields. We had cultural sensitivity training as part of the grassroots organizing strategy of being from this kind of bridge place from this college town on the outskirts of the region, but supporting folks from more frontline— directly impacted communities facing these 1000-acre strip mine permits who were asking for support from a broader base of folks.
erin wasn’t raised in the most directly impacted Appalachian communities she was organizing with, but she used her skills and knowledge of the region to support and contribute to their efforts. Educating outsiders about the negative Appalachian stereotypes they might not have previously understood was an important act of solidarity.
We used our connections to pull in more folks from away from the Northeast, from cities, and really spelled it all out about the cultural stereotypes you might have heard that says that these people are “backward” or “inbred” or “ignorant.”
[She would explain that] Theres actually really robust cultural back stories to all of that and its way more complicated than you think. And that’s an intentionally crafted, classist and bigoted stereotype that has allowed this area to be an extraction zone and has allowed these people to be seen as less than and disposable.
For erin, this time in her early twenties was an important period of self-identity cultivation. Organizing with people who were anti-strip mine but not from Appalachia helped clarify her relationship to herself and to the movement:
That was probably the first time I really claimed that identity. As a point of pride, but also a strategic organizing tool of, “Oh no, I'm more from here than y'all, at least.”
erin's time organizing in the coal fields sparked her mom’s interest in genealogy, leading to the discovery that they had ancestors who lived in the Kentucky coal fields for hundreds of years. Though she had ancestral and contemporary connections to the coal fields and efforts to advocate and support its residents, there was no doubt erin’s relationship to Appalachia and identity differed from some residents living deep in the coal fields.
Some of the folks who we were trying to convince that we were on the same team identify as Appalachian. They equally, or maybe more strongly, identify as coal miners, which we've now seen played out over the ensuing decade, politically and culturally. People were wildly suspicious of… “Not only are you different than us,” but “What is it that you're trying to do here?”
Referencing a Venn diagram, erin metaphorically described the similarities and differences between her and other Appalachians. Her work in grassroots organizing in the coal mines was impactful personally and on a community scale, but with time, the intensity of her involvement waned.
I still live in Appalachia but I spend a whole lot less time deep in the coal fields. Things have changed in the landscape in terms of the viability of that work. We reached some regulatory and strategic dead ends. Some selling out by Big Green. There were some real losses in that work. And some of my dear folks some of my comrades who I was very close within that chapter of my life have stuck around in that neck of the woods and have integrated into some of the community orgs that we helped start or were a part of, and the work is much broader.
Folks are both trying to keep new permits from coming through and hold on to the victories that we did get around mine reclamation or different things like that. But then also trying to support economic alternatives through woodland medicinals and trying to support safe community hubs for queer youth and doing a more broad-based community organizing thing.
There was a time when I thought that my future was also going to look like staying in that neck of the woods. But I realized that I have more of an opportunity, more power that I could leverage coming back to where I'm from, where I'm from from. Even though I'm only talking two and a half hours away, because of this piece of land, because of this farm.
Nature does a lot undoing some of the damage of non-ecologically minded humans. But this work is an infinite task—especially in the face of climate change.
