How to Inherit 600 Acres and Heal

By Makenna K. Clark, PhD Student Sociology Department, Virginia Tech

How to Inherit 600 Acres and Heal: An Oral History Project

One Appalachian’s Experience of Land Inheritance, Regional Identity, Ecological Restoration and Climate Resilience

Example Image
Photo of erin's Creek by Makenna K. Clark (CC BY 4.0)
Decorative Block Quote
What feels really good is that if you give a plant or a project the right conditions to grow, it will grow.

erin is a white Appalachian “femme-ish” person in her 40s, born and raised in Blacksburg, VA. She spent her childhood roaming the rolling hills and valleys of her family’s 600-acre farm that her grandfather bought in the 1970s. Land which she has since inherited. During our ninety-minute interview, erin openly shared about her life, discussing themes related to Appalachian identity, land inheritance, climate change and resilience, land stewardship, and the contours of living in a region and town that has “grown and lost so much.”

I interviewed erin on an abnormally warm Fall Day in 2024. After driving down a long, dirt driveway towards the rolling mountain ahead, I pulled off to the left and was greeted by erin’s dog, Sally. Sally and I walked up to erin’s front door, and I was warmly welcomed into a small, lofted log cabin. Cascading plants, animal bones, dried herbs, artwork, and books decorated the walls of erin’s home. Once settled in one another’s company, I began our interview by prompting erin to “Tell me about the land we are on.” Her description was slow, rich with historical insight, and unapologetically textured. It reflected the kind of intimacy only a forty-year-long relationship could.

Example Image
"Farm Use" by erin (All Rights Reserved)

erin described the land as a third parent, one that provided safe childcare and nurtured her blossoming imagination. While erin’s mom worked inside their home cooking dinner or grading papers, she played in the woods or by the creek with her friends and brother, imagining a time long before her that unfolded on the very ground she stood. erin’s mother would ring a heavy cast iron triangle when it was time to come in, and she would do it all over again the next day.

Throughout our ninety-minute interview, erin answered my questions thoughtfully and tenderly—evidence that she spends much of her private time contemplating her relationships with place, purpose, and identity. Ways of belonging and Appalachian culture were woven into erin’s childhood formally in school and informally through play and family norms. erin recalled school projects designed to educate and cultivate children’s Appalachian cultural identity. At home, Sunday drives with her dad to Floyd and Craig counties in Southwestern Virginia were regular. As she processed dried elecampane seated crisscross applesauce on the couch, she explained her father’s intentions:

He really wanted to impart on my brother and I how special it was that these folks were real living, old-timer Appalachian folks…there was some class difference between my family and some of these folks who we went to go visit… they were more- my mom was a professor. We had grown up with more land privilege and class privilege than some.

I think some of what my dad was trying to instill was his pride in these folks, his kind of respect for these folks who were from a similar but more kind of salt of the earthy background. But I do remember him talking about Appalachia. Being proud. Instilling that we come from a cool and special place, “you kids don't know how good you got it that we live around here,” kind of thing.

I didn't know how good I had it until we moved away, and then I was really homesick.

Example Image
Photo of erin in her Yard by Makenna K. Clark (CC BY 4.0)

erin doesn’t remember her mom discussing Appalachia as an explicit concept in her childhood, though family meals with her maternal grandparents would feature recurring stories about their depression-era roots, with their rural beginnings highlighting real contrast with the wealth they achieved. Her family does have deep roots with many generations on both sides connecting her to the region. Her mom went on to study and teach Appalachian Studies primarily through a literature lens and other academic cultural studies lenses. erin’s relationship with place and belonging guided her involvement in grassroots organizing efforts related to resource extraction and environmental justice, and she suspects her work doing anti-strip-mining organizing, “which at the time was very Appalachian cultural flavored,” had an impact on her mom’s pursuit of Appalachian Studies:

We would have old-time String Band fundraisers with a square dance. We organized an annual pie auction with a live auctioneer to support organizing efforts in the coal fields. We had cultural sensitivity training as part of the grassroots organizing strategy of being from this kind of bridge place from this college town on the outskirts of the region, but supporting folks from more frontline— directly impacted communities facing these 1000-acre strip mine permits who were asking for support from a broader base of folks.

erin wasn’t raised in the most directly impacted Appalachian communities she was organizing with, but she used her skills and knowledge of the region to support and contribute to their efforts. Educating outsiders about the negative Appalachian stereotypes they might not have previously understood was an important act of solidarity.

We used our connections to pull in more folks from away from the Northeast, from cities, and really spelled it all out about the cultural stereotypes you might have heard that says that these people are “backward” or “inbred” or “ignorant.”

[She would explain that] Theres actually really robust cultural back stories to all of that and its way more complicated than you think. And that’s an intentionally crafted, classist and bigoted stereotype that has allowed this area to be an extraction zone and has allowed these people to be seen as less than and disposable.

For erin, this time in her early twenties was an important period of self-identity cultivation. Organizing with people who were anti-strip mine but not from Appalachia helped clarify her relationship to herself and to the movement:

That was probably the first time I really claimed that identity. As a point of pride, but also a strategic organizing tool of, “Oh no, I'm more from here than y'all, at least.”

erin's time organizing in the coal fields sparked her mom’s interest in genealogy, leading to the discovery that they had ancestors who lived in the Kentucky coal fields for hundreds of years. Though she had ancestral and contemporary connections to the coal fields and efforts to advocate and support its residents, there was no doubt erin’s relationship to Appalachia and identity differed from some residents living deep in the coal fields.

Some of the folks who we were trying to convince that we were on the same team identify as Appalachian. They equally, or maybe more strongly, identify as coal miners, which we've now seen played out over the ensuing decade, politically and culturally. People were wildly suspicious of… “Not only are you different than us,” but “What is it that you're trying to do here?”

Referencing a Venn diagram, erin metaphorically described the similarities and differences between her and other Appalachians. Her work in grassroots organizing in the coal mines was impactful personally and on a community scale, but with time, the intensity of her involvement waned.

I still live in Appalachia but I spend a whole lot less time deep in the coal fields. Things have changed in the landscape in terms of the viability of that work. We reached some regulatory and strategic dead ends. Some selling out by Big Green. There were some real losses in that work. And some of my dear folks some of my comrades who I was very close within that chapter of my life have stuck around in that neck of the woods and have integrated into some of the community orgs that we helped start or were a part of, and the work is much broader.

Folks are both trying to keep new permits from coming through and hold on to the victories that we did get around mine reclamation or different things like that. But then also trying to support economic alternatives through woodland medicinals and trying to support safe community hubs for queer youth and doing a more broad-based community organizing thing.

There was a time when I thought that my future was also going to look like staying in that neck of the woods. But I realized that I have more of an opportunity, more power that I could leverage coming back to where I'm from, where I'm from from. Even though I'm only talking two and a half hours away, because of this piece of land, because of this farm.

Example Image
Wooden Fence by Makenna K. Clark (CC BY 4.0)
Decorative Block Quote
Nature does a lot undoing some of the damage of non-ecologically minded humans. But this work is an infinite task—especially in the face of climate change.

Throughout her 20’s, erin was mentored by “plant grannies,” who taught her all of what she knew about plant medicine. At the time of our interview, erin explained many of her mentors have since died—usually as a result of cancer or other health conditions related to living in or around coal mining and other resource extraction sites. As a result of these losses, erin grapples with the ebbs and flows related to being a keeper of surviving knowledge and wonders how to transmit generational wisdom most effectively.

Not really any of the folks who were my organizer and Forest Granny, plant mentors, are still alive. They've all died of cancer, basically, from my time deeper in the coal fields. And that is the reality. Its this heartbreaking irony of people who are more connected to a land base and land-based skills and knowledge have also been on the receiving end of way more environmental toxicity: less nutritious food, shittier access to healthcare, and have died young. And the stress of having your whole existence be fighting this thing that's hundreds of years with billions of dollars behind it that's trying to literally snatch the ground underneath your home.

The flavor of erin’s work has changed but there is no shortage in the quantity of her efforts. erin explained that now she spends a lot of time fighting frack gas pipelines and supporting mutual aid efforts. She is “continuing to try to strengthen the fabric of people who live here, who are looking out for each other and doing good stuff.” Supporting these efforts and contributing to social justice efforts is instinctual for erin, but outmigration and climate change have made participation challenging and, at times, painful. Reflecting on her organizing efforts now compared to before, she described:

One of the big differences is that there are so few folks who are generationally rooted, compared to then. Now I am the person who's from here and most of the folks who I'm working with are not. I’m maybe always a little bit holding my breath that anybody who I am connecting and building with is going to get to a point where they feel over this crappy, militarized college town and move on to somewhere else.

erin wrestles with the realities of living in the place she grew up, a place where so much has changed. Farms she used to play on or pass by as a kid are now subdivisions for student housing, and remote working insulates people from opportunities that would have previously cultivated community and place-making. erin has stepped away from some cultural practices like square dancing—partly due to COVID-19 and her shifting comfort around crowds—but erin explained that some feelings of attachment have also shifted after losing mentors and members of the community she grew close to during her time organizing in the coal fields. The changes in her sense of close community have shifted, but she displayed an honest curiosity as to why, and a tenderness that leaves room for a variety of change forces.

Now, living full-time on her family’s farmland on the outskirts of Blacksburg, VA, erin focuses on ecological restoration and planting medicinal crops, adapting to climate change challenges. She emphasizes the importance of long-term, community-based land stewardship and the intergenerational impact of her work. The land erin has focused her attention on has a long history, which she is intimately familiar with and continues to educate herself about. erin’s deep knowledge of the land shapes her personal and political aspirations.

Like most agricultural land in this neck of the woods, there is a dark history of plantation time enslavement. This was a part of a so-called plantation that was many 1000s of acres, stretched the hole up and down the valley. Prior to that, it was a land grant from the King in colonial times. We are a little bit further West than the western boundary of the original colony. But there was a while during settler times in the 16 and 1700s when this was the “wild western frontier.”

This is the territory of the people who call themselves the Yésah. I grew up hearing that this was Monacan land, and then more recently learned that the more a local band is Tutelo, and then more recently, learned that their own name for themselves is the Yésah. I've always wished that I knew what they call this mountain or this river, but I don't know whether or not they gave them names.

One thing that I learned that really gives me a lens to think about what came before colonization on this land I learned from my mom when she was young. The Country Club is a few miles south of here. In the 60s, they were excavating to put in a swimming pool and encountered an archeological site of what was a palisaded village site from the eastern woodland times the ancestors of the more recent day Tutelo.

It was a village site that had been surrounded by a wall of upright timbers. There were ancestors’ remains, and they found all kinds of artifacts. My grandfather brought my mom with him to go. He got an invitation to go see the archeological dig, and she was there and looked down on some of the remains and sites that were found. And it was incredibly profound and impactful to her, and I think really opened her eyes to an interest in Turtle Island's indigenous history.

As a kid and throughout my time here on the farm, we've found arrowheads. We are definitely within the frequently used area of those peoples. I am intrigued, I'm curious, and now I am also mad and frustrated to think that those ancestry remains are in a drawer in some museum in Richmond or something shitty. I would love to offer this land as somewhere for rematriation of remains because were the closest, biggest intact piece of forest to that area.

When I came back onto this land, I left a lot of the community that I've been investing in. So now I feel I'm really challenging myself to not just love my time in the woods and walking on the hill and in the Creek, but really think about how this increasingly rare big piece of land can be preserved.

With whom does it make sense to try to share access to this place? To what are the best uses going forward? How? How can there be a combination of producing food here and preserving open space? And what does it mean to have dreams of transferring land out of private family ownership into some more community? What are the different versions of that?

Ecological restoration is now a big part of erin’s life. The cattle farming her grandfather enacted on the farm degraded the riverbanks and the watershed and prioritized grass above all else. She has a long list of land projects to address and restore the land. And like any project, these take time and labor.

Nature does a lot undoing some of the damage of non-ecologically minded humans. But this work is an infinite task—especially in the face of climate change. Increasing droughts and increasing opportunistic troublesome species, and insect plagues are killing trees.

Its been a good, steady, and tangible focus to work on ecological restoration work while visioning and scheming and trying to plant seeds for what the future of this farm beyond my own family is going to look like.

Example Image
Cows in a Pasture by erin (All Rights Reserved)

Some restoration projects include fencing the cows out of the waterways, planting trees, and invasive species mitigation and removal, and preparing for droughts. There are places in the woods where the understory is damaged because cows were allowed to graze up the hills. To help heal and nurture the understory, erin has planted stands of ginseng, golden seal, Solomon seal, and other woodland medicines that a mentor of hers, Carol Judy, shared during their time together.

She taught me about how you could, at the end of the growing season—right before all the sang harvesters would come through—pull off most of the leaves so that the ginseng wouldn't be quickly spotted or identified. It would be a little bit of nutrient cost to the plant, maybe it didn't have the full end of the season to bring all those sugars from the leaves down to its roots, but a harm reduction model of keeping it because, because of economic pressures and not everybody having access to a, solid, pragmatic forest granny who would knock some sense into them about over harvesting.

All those plants are wildly threatened, over-harvested, and completely stripped from the woods. So she would to guard these stands preciously and do all these different things to protect them. But every time I would go and spend time with her, she'd send me home with a little zip lock baggie packed with some moist moss with little rootlets and seeds of different woodland crops made in here, fern and ‘seng and trillium. These beautiful plants.

So the first, as soon as I was able to get, kind of a promise of protection to a piece of woods up in the mountain here that the cows would stay fenced out of them. We've been calling it the Carol Judy Woods and, for a decade, planting little bits.

erin explained that her ideas about ecological restoration ten years ago have shifted because of how quickly climate change has impacted Virginia in terms of rainfall and temperature changes. What were once realistic measures are no longer viable. For example, the sugar maples erin planted years ago—because she loves tapping trees and they benefit the overall environment—rely on freeze and thaw times. Without predictable or reliable Winter and Spring temperatures, these trees do not hold the certainty in erin’s vision as they once did.

I feel very anxious about the drought. That seems to just be the increasing norm. So much of the magic of Appalachia is its temperate rainforest. And it's wild that I got to spend a lot of really formative time learning about plant medicine and plant communities in the forests that are all there because of the high amount of rainfall that they get.

To adapt to changes associated with climate change, erin is in partnership with the cattle farmer who leases much of the pastureland she owns. They collaborate on sustainable farming efforts, and the relationship and willingness to learn are mutually beneficial because ecologically sustainable pasture techniques are also cost-effective. She has also partnered with a graduate student from Virginia Tech who is passionate about ecologically sustainable pasture production. Together, they are developing plans for a Silvopasture project—which involves the intentional integration of forages, trees, and livestock. These systems are designed and managed in ways that increase productivity on a unit of land by producing livestock and timber products. erin is thinking into the future and planning accordingly:

Maybe I should plant pecans in the silvopasture range. Maybe I need to think about what's a couple of zones South of here and invest in the future in terms of plant communities that can handle heat and dryness.

erin’s journey of learning how to be climate resilient is ongoing. She took a year-long community herbalism course and has made regional connections with other farmers grappling with the realities of climate change. She takes the politics of plant knowledge seriously and is careful not to participate in knowledge hoarding or gatekeeping. She remains critical of plant knowledge as a specialized skill instead of a collective heritage of knowing.

There can be a colonial mindset in a lot of these different plant and farming communities that I'm really trying to not replicate or buy into, even though I am the recipient of that colonial heritage that says that this plot of land belongs to my family.

There are a lot of uncertainties, but erin is open to learning, and adapting, and remains open to change. Our conversation was difficult at times; these topics take a lifetime to understand. Some of them, we might never fully. In the spirit of ending on a high note, I asked erin what feels good about life right now. After pausing, she said:

What feels really good is that if you give a plant or a project the right conditions to grow, it will grow. I'm maybe extra freaked out about the drought right now because it's been such a horrifyingly scarily dry couple of months this fall but it's so amazing to see when things grow and thrive. So many of the medicinal plants that I'm really excited about are long-lived or perennials that you get established, and then they do their own thing. They're kind of wild and weedy. My partner and I have been building what we call the Solidarity Row.

It's this big, long, kind of patchwork quilt-styled garden with a bunch of medicinal plants that are just basically wildflowers. There’s mondara, there's echinacea, there's anise hyssop, there's elecampane, there's lavender, all these plants, some of which are native to this area, some of which are brought in because they're useful for us.

But once they're there, they're doing their own thing, and seeing that take shape over the past few years has been really exciting.

Example Image
The Garden by erin (All Rights Reserved)
Decorative Block Quote
There was a time when I thought that my future was also going to look like staying in that neck of the woods. But I realized that I have more of an opportunity, more power that I could leverage coming back to where I'm from, where I'm from from.
Example Image
erin in Her Yard by Makenna K. Clark (CC BY 4.0)

The contours of erin’s ever-unfolding life story is a testament to the adaptability and innovative spirit that flows through Appalachia. erin has a gracious patience that I have never quite encountered. She is a highly skilled, intelligent, ambitious, charming, and critical Appalachian person, and her company compels me to speak less and listen more. Learning more about her background—accompanied by her descriptions of the present and aspirational visions for the future— was like fitting a puzzle piece snug where it belongs. It made sense. It couldn’t have been any other way. Like her Solidarity Row, erin’s patchwork life will grow wild and weedy with purpose. I left my interview with a handful of freshly cut catnip, a bag of homegrown jalapeños, and an unmistakable sense of being alive.

Example Image
erin's Chickens by erin (All Rights Reserved)

*Note: Words like “um” and “like” have been removed for readability.

*Note: erin spells her name with a lower-case E.